Judicial Review Decisions

A judicial review is when a person asks the Supreme Court of British Columbia to review a decision of the Board. A person can then appeal the Supreme Court’s decision to the BC Court of Appeal.

This table shows each Board decision that a court has reviewed, with the court decisions beside it. Court decisions open on the BC Courts website or CanLII. Before you rely on a Board decision, check this table to see if a court has reviewed it.

Board decisionBC Supreme CourtBC Court of Appeal
Ghalia Rebei Adlani (Moonlight Daycare) v. Dr. Emily Newhouse, Medical Health Officer, Fraser Health Authority, 2023 BCCCALAB 1Decided February 7, 2023Adlani v. Medical Health Officer (Fraser Health Authority), 2024 BCSC 84Vancouver Registry S232798Decided January 17, 2024Adlani v. Fraser Health Authority (Medical Health Officer), 2025 BCCA 29Vancouver Registry CA49672Decided January 24, 2025
Summaries 14, 42, and 43Summary only. Read the summaries on the Pre-2004 Decisions pageSummers v. Ministry of Health-Community Care, 2004 BCSC 1349Decided October 20, 2004—
Summary 21Summary only. Read the summary on the Pre-2004 Decisions pageJohnson v. BlatherwickVancouver Registry A981070Decided October 13, 1999Not available online—
Summary 23Summary only. Read the summary on the Pre-2004 Decisions pageLoewen v. Community Care Facility Appeal BoardVancouver Registry A990061Decided August 31, 1999Not available online—
Summary 12Summary only. Read the summary on the Pre-2004 Decisions pageLittle v. Benson, 1996 CanLII 1893 (BC SC)Nanaimo Registry 12763Decided May 13, 1996—
Summary 5Summary only. Read the summary on the Pre-2004 Decisions pageKucher v. BensonVancouver Registry A943253Decided January 23, 1995—

Each row is one Board decision. A dash means the court decision was not appealed or there is no decision to show.